Hello dear
Welcome to Tony’s of NY
At Tony’s of NY, located in Timonium, Maryland, a slice of New York pizza meets heartfelt hospitality. Founded by culinary enthusiasts Sergio and Antonio, this inviting establishment offers a delightful menu, showcasing fresh salads, beloved classic dishes, and authentic Brooklyn-style pizzas. Diners rave about the impeccable crust, rich sauce, and generous toppings, making the pizza a standout in the region. The lively atmosphere, combined with friendly service, truly makes patrons feel at home. Whether you savor the creamy Caesar salad or indulge in the savory short rib ravioli, Tony's promises a delicious dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Fountain Drink
12" Brooklyn Style Margherita D.O.P.
12" Brooklyn Style Chicken & Broccoli Delight
12" Brooklyn Style Chicken Parmigiana
About
Tony’s of NY
Welcome to Tony's of NY, a culinary gem located at 12218 Tullamore Rd, Timonium, MD. Known for its authentic New York-style pizza and hearty subs, Tony's has quickly become a beloved local hotspot. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, it's a perfect place to enjoy a meal with friends and family.
The menu at Tony's is impressive and diverse, featuring signature items that keep customers coming back for more:
- Cheesesteaks: Indulge in the Original, featuring 100% chopped ribeye or chicken breast, complemented by fried onions, American cheese, and a selection of toppings, all served on a delectable 10-inch Italian sub roll.
- Classic N.Y. Subs: The Italian Stallion is a standout choice, packed with ham, salami, capicolla, and provolone on an artisan Italian baguette, ensuring by-the-bite satisfaction.
- Brooklyn Style Pizza: Hand-tossed and generously topped, the 16-inch Brooklyn Style Pizza is a must-try, whether you opt for classic cheese or the savory combo with three toppings for the price of two.
But don't just take my word for it. Local patrons sing praises of Tony's offerings. Tim K. raves about the "best pizza in the area," highlighting the quality and care that goes into every dish. Meanwhile, Michael Schectman confidently states it’s "the greatest pizza in Maryland," emphasizing the immaculate sauce and perfectly cooked crust.
One of my personal favorites is the White Garlicky Pizza, which is a delightfully aromatic slice that doesn't even need reheating. Each bite exudes flavor, leaving you craving more. I appreciate how the team at Tony's provides a BYOB experience, encouraging guests to bring their favorite bottle of wine to elevate their dining experience.
Despite its casual counter-service format, the level of service at Tony's is exceptional. Customers like Adam Baylus feel like VIPs, greeted by name and treated like family. This friendly atmosphere enhances the overall experience, making it a delightful destination for any occasion.
Situated in a friendly neighborhood, Tony's of NY combines quality food with a welcoming vibe, making it a standout eatery in Timonium. Whether you’re indulging in mouth-watering pizza, subs, or simply enjoying a sunny afternoon at one of its few outdoor tables, Tony's is definitely a place worth visiting.
If you’re looking to satisfy your cravings for genuine New York-style cuisine, look no further than Tony’s of NY — where excellent food and friendly service create an unforgettable dining experience.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I was told about Tony's of NY by a family member and I have been back several times. They have one of the best pizza's in the area and the subs are good as well. Everyone here has been friendly and they take pride in the food they serve. I'll definitely continue to patronize this establishment. ”
“ The restaurant was packed but we were quickly acknowledged and able to order. It's a nice place to hang out after the lunch crowd leaves. The Hawaiian pizza had lots of ham and pineapple and the house salad dressing was the best! ”
“ Without question, the greatest pizza in the state of Maryland and rivals ANY pizza from any other state, let alone country or continent. The sauce is immaculate, the crust is cooked to literal perfection, the cheese is sensational, and the people who work there are incredibly nice and hard working. A pleasure to visit and a pleasure to do business with. ”
“ I work right next door to Tony's, and I am absolutely delighted that they chose here to begin their new enterprise. Sergio and Antonio know what they're doing, and they inspire the folks working with them. When I walk in there, I feel like I'm home...They know my name...They pretty much always know what I want, unless I mix it up! :-) I could live on the Ceasar Salad with Grilled Chicken...and the White Garlicky Pizza--it's on the by-the-slice row, and seriously, you don't need to heat it up. The flavors are incredible! And what makes this destination restaurant even more special, you can bring your favorite bottle of wine-- or shop next door (that's where I am :-) ) and enjoy it with this fantastic cuisine! Special thanks to Freddie, Sol, Josie---and I wish I knew more names--for always making me feel like a VIP! ”
“ If you enjoy genuine extra greasy NY-style pizza, this place is for you! This is a counter-service, BYOB restaurant where they will bring your meal out to you. When I walked in on a Friday evening, the restaurant was about half full with about a dozen workers in the kitchen. Two workers at the counter took my order right away. I only had to wait about 15 minutes for my pepperoni with extra cheese 16” pizza to come to my table. Be careful! Pizzas can slide off the pizza stands easily. The pepperoni here has a spicy, sausage-like flavor. Despite the unique quality of the pepperoni, I found my pizza delicious with or without the powdered garlic topping. My only qualm with Tony’s is that the crust appeared pre-fabricated (not freshly made). Despite the unusual uniformity of the crust, I still found my pizza outrageously delicious. The counter staff even waved goodbye. There are only six small outside tables available. However, if you can grab one during pleasant weather, this makes a great place to pass the afternoon. I’d recommend trying Tony’s whether you want to carry-out or dine-in. ”
“ This place has great food, very nice atmosphere, and an awesome staff. The Brooklyn style pizza is highly recommended. BYOB from the liquor store next door is a great option. We enjoyed some wine with our dinner. They even opened the bottle and provided wine glasses. Definitely worth checking out. Best pizza I’ve had in the area. Great addition to the Mays Chapel community. We will be back!! ”
“ After a long anticipated wait Tony’s is finally open! I was able to eat there last night for the first time! Food was amazing service was fast and very friendly! We look forward to many more visits to Tony’s! Crabby Tots are out of this world!! ”
“ I love this place!!!! My friends and I come all the time, and it’s just a great hang out spot. The pizza is great, so are the other foods. Coming here after school is so fun!! The service is so fast and everyone there is so friendly . This place opening has been amazing for me, and it’s definitely a weeknight staple! Come to Tony’s!! ”